Ducktail

Anything is possible and a decent artist would be able to do it.

That said the geometrics is just not compatible in my opinion – the bottom piece (Aztec??) is a very eye catching piece but is also a complex pattern.

To have that slapped into the star would draw the eye in 2 different directions and may not make for a good tattoo. (Not to be offensive here just been honest).

Have you considered the bottom piece with some extra surrounding other than a star – eg similar tribal patterning?

The star by itself would also make a nice tattoo.

Matthew